| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Collodi | FC Dallas | vs St. Louis CITY SC | 16' | MLS | 7 Sept 2025 |
| Jovan Lukic | Philadelphia Union | vs Atlanta United FC | 56' | MLS | 19 Apr 2025 |
| Scott Arfield | Charlotte FC | vs Orlando City SC | 38' | MLS | 19 Jun 2024 |
| Kevin Long | Toronto FC | vs Charlotte FC | 90' | MLS | 13 Apr 2024 |
| Gustavo Vallecilla | Colorado Rapids | vs Philadelphia Union | 35' | MLS | 27 Aug 2022 |
| Romain Métanire | Minnesota United FC | vs Philadelphia Union | 77' | MLS | 21 Oct 2021 |
| Diego Chará | Portland Timbers | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 90' | MLS | 5 Aug 2021 |
| Dru Yearwood | Red Bull New York | vs Philadelphia Union | 90' | MLS | 15 May 2021 |