| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steven Beitashour | San Jose Earthquakes | vs LA Galaxy | 81' | MLS | 21 Aug 2011 |
| Conor Casey | Colorado Rapids | vs Columbus Crew | 29' | MLS | 27 Jun 2011 |
| Carlos Mendes | Red Bull New York | vs New England Revolution | 56' | MLS | 30 May 2010 |
| Roy Miller | Red Bull New York | vs New England Revolution | 76' | MLS | 30 May 2010 |
| Luke Sassano | Red Bull New York | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 12' | MLS | 9 May 2010 |