| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Clucas | Hull City | vs Arsenal | 90' | Premier League | 11 Feb 2017 |
| Phil Jagielka | Everton | vs Arsenal | 90' | Premier League | 13 Dec 2016 |
| Ander Herrera | Manchester United | vs Burnley | 68' | Premier League | 29 Oct 2016 |
| Jordan Henderson | Liverpool | vs Manchester City | 90' | Premier League | 13 Apr 2014 |
| Nemanja Vidic | Manchester United | vs Liverpool | 77' | Premier League | 16 Mar 2014 |
| Kevin Nolan | West Ham United | vs Fulham | 44' | Premier League | 1 Jan 2014 |
| Grant Holt | Norwich City | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 85' | Premier League | 24 Mar 2012 |
| Djibril Cissé | Queens Park Rangers | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 34' | Premier League | 4 Feb 2012 |
| Gaël Clichy | Manchester City | vs Chelsea | 58' | Premier League | 12 Dec 2011 |
| Ricardo Gardner | Bolton Wanderers | vs Swansea City | 48' | Premier League | 29 Oct 2011 |
| Jonny Evans | Manchester United | vs Manchester City | 47' | Premier League | 23 Oct 2011 |
| David Wheater | Bolton Wanderers | vs Arsenal | 55' | Premier League | 24 Sept 2011 |
| Gaël Givet | Blackburn Rovers | vs Fulham | 90' | Premier League | 5 Mar 2011 |
| Mark Davies | Bolton Wanderers | vs Blackburn Rovers | 56' | Premier League | 12 Dec 2010 |
| Dedryck Boyata | Manchester City | vs Arsenal | 5' | Premier League | 24 Oct 2010 |
| Craig Gardner | Birmingham City | vs Wigan Athletic | 89' | Premier League | 25 Sept 2010 |