| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Isaiah Parente | LA Galaxy | vs FC Cincinnati | 51' | MLS | 21 Sept 2025 |
| DeJuan Jones | San Jose Earthquakes | vs Red Bull New York | 64' | MLS | 6 Jul 2025 |
| Raheem Edwards | Red Bull New York | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 87' | MLS | 6 Jul 2025 |
| Zack Steffen | Colorado Rapids | vs Houston Dynamo FC | 90' | MLS | 20 Apr 2025 |
| Cristián Dájome | D.C. United | vs Red Bull New York | 20' | MLS | 29 Jun 2024 |
| Steve Birnbaum | D.C. United | vs Real Salt Lake | 26' | MLS | 17 Jun 2023 |