| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Hamid | D.C. United | vs Red Bull New York | 69' | MLS | 9 Nov 2012 |
| Rafael Márquez | Red Bull New York | vs D.C. United | 75' | MLS | 9 Nov 2012 |
| Diego Chará | Portland Timbers | vs Real Salt Lake | 73' | MLS | 8 Jul 2012 |
| Davi Lopes | LA Galaxy | vs Chivas USA | 70' | MLS | 20 May 2012 |
| Jeb Brovsky | CF Montréal | vs Columbus Crew | 19' | MLS | 24 Mar 2012 |
| Jeff Larentowicz | Colorado Rapids | vs Philadelphia Union | 58' | MLS | 18 Mar 2012 |
| Carlos Costly | Houston Dynamo FC | vs Sporting Kansas City | 64' | MLS | 10 Sept 2011 |
| Jordan Harvey | Philadelphia Union | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 41' | MLS | 30 Apr 2011 |
| Geoff Cameron | Houston Dynamo FC | vs New England Revolution | 90' | MLS | 11 Oct 2010 |
| Joseph Ngwenya | Houston Dynamo FC | vs New England Revolution | 90' | MLS | 11 Oct 2010 |
| Gonzalo Segares | Chicago Fire FC | vs LA Galaxy | 22' | MLS | 4 Sept 2010 |