| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyrone Marshall | Colorado Rapids | vs CF Montréal | 61' | MLS | 27 May 2012 |
| Tony Beltran | Real Salt Lake | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 35' | MLS | 10 Sept 2011 |
| Jhon Kennedy Hurtado | Seattle Sounders FC | vs Real Salt Lake | 39' | MLS | 10 Sept 2011 |
| Andy Nájar | D.C. United | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 71' | MLS | 31 Jul 2011 |
| Jamison Olave | Real Salt Lake | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 58' | MLS | 29 May 2011 |
| Ty Harden | Toronto FC | vs D.C. United | 49' | MLS | 16 Apr 2011 |