| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reid Roberts | San Jose Earthquakes | vs Real Salt Lake | 83' | MLS | 27 Jul 2025 |
| Olwethu Makhanya | Philadelphia Union | vs Nashville SC | 90' | MLS | 16 Mar 2025 |
| Kevin O'Toole | New York City FC | vs Orlando City SC | 86' | MLS | 9 Mar 2025 |
| Bruno Wilson | San Jose Earthquakes | vs Portland Timbers | 71' | MLS | 16 May 2024 |
| Cucho Hernández | Columbus Crew | vs D.C. United | 75' | MLS | 6 Apr 2024 |
| Cameron Harper | Red Bull New York | vs Inter Miami CF | 90' | MLS | 1 Jun 2023 |
| Christopher Durkin | D.C. United | vs Inter Miami CF | 90' | MLS | 15 May 2022 |
| Moses Nyeman | D.C. United | vs FC Cincinnati | 80' | MLS | 5 Mar 2022 |