| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cristián Dájome | Vancouver Whitecaps | vs LA Galaxy | 79' | MLS | 14 Aug 2022 |
| Federico Navarro | Chicago Fire FC | vs Minnesota United FC | 77' | MLS | 23 Apr 2022 |
| Hector Jimenez | Austin FC | vs FC Dallas | 58' | MLS | 31 Oct 2021 |
| Stephen McCarthy | New England Revolution | vs Sporting Kansas City | 14' | MLS | 18 Mar 2012 |
| Miguel Comminges | Colorado Rapids | vs FC Dallas | 74' | MLS | 2 Oct 2011 |
| Brian Mullan | Colorado Rapids | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 4' | MLS | 23 Apr 2011 |
| Mikael-David Yourassowsky | Toronto FC | vs Portland Timbers | 81' | MLS | 26 Mar 2011 |