| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leandro Cufré | vs Germany | 120' | Ľuboš Micheľ | 2006 FIFA World Cup | 30 Jun 2006 |
| Claudio Caniggia | vs Sweden | 45' | Ali Bujsaim | 2002 FIFA World Cup | 12 Jun 2002 |
| Ariel Ortega | vs Netherlands | 87' | Arturo Brizio Carter | 1998 FIFA World Cup | 4 Jul 1998 |
| Pedro Monzón | vs West Germany | 65' | Edgardo Codesal | 1990 FIFA World Cup | 8 Jul 1990 |
| Gustavo Dezotti | vs West Germany | 87' | Edgardo Codesal | 1990 FIFA World Cup | 8 Jul 1990 |
| Ricardo Giusti | vs Italy | 103' | Michel Vautrot | 1990 FIFA World Cup | 3 Jul 1990 |