| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paul Nebel | vs SC Freiburg | 28' | Daniel Schlager | Bundesliga | 30 Nov 2025 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs TSG Hoffenheim | 88' | Sascha Stegemann | Bundesliga | 21 Nov 2025 |
| Robin Zentner | vs Borussia Dortmund | 67' | Tobias Reichel | Bundesliga | 27 Sept 2025 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs FC Augsburg | 53' | Daniel Schlager | Bundesliga | 20 Sept 2025 |
| Paul Nebel | vs FC Cologne | 60' | Tobias Stieler | Bundesliga | 24 Aug 2025 |
| Paul Nebel | vs TSG Hoffenheim | 90' | Sven Jablonski | Bundesliga | 12 Apr 2025 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs SC Freiburg | 43' | Benjamin Brand | Bundesliga | 15 Mar 2025 |
| Nadiem Amiri | vs Eintracht Frankfurt | 21' | Florian Badstübner | Bundesliga | 21 Dec 2024 |
| Andreas Hanche-Olsen | vs 1. FC Heidenheim 1846 | 29' | Florian Exner | Bundesliga | 28 Sept 2024 |
| Nadiem Amiri | vs FC Augsburg | 35' | Sören Storks | Bundesliga | 20 Sept 2024 |
| Phillipp Mwene | vs FC Cologne | 90' | Benjamin Brand | Bundesliga | 28 Apr 2024 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs Borussia Mönchengladbach | 84' | Robert Schröder | Bundesliga | 2 Mar 2024 |
| Jessic Ngankam | vs Bayer Leverkusen | 80' | Timo Gerach | Bundesliga | 23 Feb 2024 |
| Alexander Hack | vs TSG Hoffenheim | 41' | Daniel Schlager | Bundesliga | 10 Sept 2022 |
| Niklas Tauer | vs VfL Wolfsburg | 23' | Harm Osmers | Bundesliga | 22 Apr 2022 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs 1. FC Union Berlin | 60' | Bastian Dankert | Bundesliga | 26 Feb 2022 |
| Alexander Hack | vs RB Leipzig | 19' | Deniz Aytekin | Bundesliga | 8 Jan 2022 |
| Dominik Kohr | vs 1. FC Union Berlin | 90' | Tobias Stieler | Bundesliga | 3 Oct 2021 |
| Moussa Niakhaté | vs VfB Stuttgart | 77' | – | Bundesliga | 26 Sept 2020 |
| Jean-Philippe Mateta | vs Fortuna Düsseldorf | 77' | – | Bundesliga | 8 Mar 2020 |
| Ridle Baku | vs TSG Hoffenheim | 45' | – | Bundesliga | 24 Nov 2019 |
| Edimilson Fernandes | vs Fortuna Düsseldorf | 45' | – | Bundesliga | 19 Oct 2019 |
| Giulio Donati | vs FC Cologne | 90' | – | Bundesliga | 7 Apr 2018 |
| Leon Balogun | vs Hamburg SV | 61' | – | Bundesliga | 3 Mar 2018 |
| Giulio Donati | vs FC Cologne | 71' | – | Bundesliga | 18 Nov 2017 |
| Jean-Philippe Gbamin | vs RB Leipzig | 89' | – | Bundesliga | 5 Apr 2017 |
| Stefan Bell | vs SV Darmstadt 98 | 89' | – | Bundesliga | 11 Mar 2017 |
| Jhon Córdoba | vs Eintracht Frankfurt | 55' | – | Bundesliga | 20 Dec 2016 |
| Jean-Philippe Gbamin | vs Borussia Mönchengladbach | 90' | – | Bundesliga | 11 Dec 2016 |
| Jean-Philippe Gbamin | vs Hertha Berlin | 62' | – | Bundesliga | 27 Nov 2016 |
| José Rodríguez | vs FC Augsburg | 90' | – | Bundesliga | 18 Sept 2016 |
| Gaëtan Bussmann | vs TSG Hoffenheim | 57' | – | Bundesliga | 11 Sept 2016 |
| Giulio Donati | vs SV Darmstadt 98 | 57' | – | Bundesliga | 6 Mar 2016 |
| Daniel Brosinski | vs Hamburg SV | 89' | – | Bundesliga | 3 May 2015 |
| Loris Karius | vs Hertha Berlin | 32' | – | Bundesliga | 7 Feb 2015 |
| Niko Bungert | vs Borussia Dortmund | 78' | – | Bundesliga | 19 Apr 2014 |
| Petar Sliskovic | vs 1. FC Nürnberg | 90' | – | Bundesliga | 6 Dec 2013 |
| Elkin Soto | vs Borussia Dortmund | 78' | – | Bundesliga | 30 Nov 2013 |
| Christian Wetklo | vs FC Augsburg | 88' | Bastian Dankert | Bundesliga | 3 Nov 2013 |
| Shawn Parker | vs FC Augsburg | 45' | – | Bundesliga | 10 Feb 2013 |
| Shawn Parker | vs SC Freiburg | 89' | – | Bundesliga | 19 Jan 2013 |
| Christian Wetklo | vs Hannover 96 | 49' | – | Bundesliga | 1 Dec 2012 |
| Julian Baumgartlinger | vs Eintracht Frankfurt | 88' | – | Bundesliga | 27 Nov 2012 |
| Ádám Szalai | vs 1. FC Nürnberg | 84' | – | Bundesliga | 10 Mar 2012 |
| Eugen Polanski | vs VfB Stuttgart | 83' | – | Bundesliga | 4 Nov 2011 |
| Nikolce Noveski | vs Hannover 96 | 45' | Thorsten Kinhöfer | Bundesliga | 9 Apr 2011 |