| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sam Byram | West Ham United | vs Sunderland | 90' | Premier League | 15 Apr 2017 |
| Ahmed Elmohamady | Hull City | vs Liverpool | 29' | Premier League | 24 Sept 2016 |
| Ryan Shawcross | Stoke City | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 52' | Premier League | 26 Apr 2014 |
| Kieran Gibbs | Arsenal | vs Chelsea | 15' | Premier League | 22 Mar 2014 |
| Danny Rose | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Manchester City | 50' | Premier League | 29 Jan 2014 |
| Lee Cattermole | Sunderland | vs Hull City | 45' | Premier League | 2 Nov 2013 |
| Andrea Dossena | Sunderland | vs Hull City | 45' | Premier League | 2 Nov 2013 |
| Steven Taylor | Newcastle United | vs Manchester City | 45' | Premier League | 19 Aug 2013 |
| Steve Sidwell | Fulham | vs Arsenal | 12' | Premier League | 20 Apr 2013 |
| Olivier Giroud | Arsenal | vs Fulham | 90' | Premier League | 20 Apr 2013 |
| Ricardo Fuller | Stoke City | vs Chelsea | 25' | Premier League | 10 Mar 2012 |
| Nathan Dyer | Swansea City | vs Wigan Athletic | 60' | Premier League | 3 Mar 2012 |
| Gaël Givet | Blackburn Rovers | vs Arsenal | 43' | Premier League | 4 Feb 2012 |
| Ashley Cole | Chelsea | vs Swansea City | 86' | Premier League | 31 Jan 2012 |
| David Dunn | Blackburn Rovers | vs Wigan Athletic | 48' | Premier League | 19 Nov 2011 |
| Jonny Evans | Manchester United | vs Bolton Wanderers | 76' | Premier League | 19 Mar 2011 |
| Aleksandar Kolarov | Manchester City | vs Bolton Wanderers | 78' | Premier League | 4 Dec 2010 |
| Lee Cattermole | Sunderland | vs Wigan Athletic | 22' | Premier League | 11 Sept 2010 |