| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jake O'Brien | Everton | vs AFC Bournemouth | 69' | Premier League | 10 Feb 2026 |
| Luke O'Nien | Sunderland | vs Manchester City | 90' | Premier League | 6 Dec 2025 |
| Mohammed Kudus | West Ham United | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 86' | Premier League | 19 Oct 2024 |
| Jordan Ayew | Crystal Palace | vs Liverpool | 75' | Premier League | 9 Dec 2023 |
| Matheus Nunes | Wolverhampton Wanderers | vs Brighton & Hove Albion | 90' | Premier League | 19 Aug 2023 |
| Cristian Romero | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Manchester City | 87' | Premier League | 5 Feb 2023 |
| Tyrick Mitchell | Crystal Palace | vs Fulham | 34' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2022 |
| James Tomkins | Crystal Palace | vs Fulham | 57' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2022 |
| Ciaran Clark | Newcastle United | vs Norwich City | 9' | Premier League | 30 Nov 2021 |