| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shapi Suleymanov | Sporting Kansas City | vs LA Galaxy | 83' | MLS | 28 Sept 2025 |
| Rafael Santos | Orlando City SC | vs CF Montréal | 76' | MLS | 19 Apr 2025 |
| Alejandro Pozuelo | Inter Miami CF | vs Red Bull New York | 29' | MLS | 27 Aug 2022 |
| Kyle Duncan | Red Bull New York | vs Inter Miami CF | 70' | MLS | 27 Aug 2022 |
| Cameron Duke | Sporting Kansas City | vs Austin FC | 43' | MLS | 31 Jul 2022 |
| Gregore | Inter Miami CF | vs D.C. United | 56' | MLS | 20 Jun 2021 |
| Ryan Shawcross | Inter Miami CF | vs D.C. United | 84' | MLS | 20 Jun 2021 |
| DeJuan Jones | New England Revolution | vs Chicago Fire FC | 90' | MLS | 18 Apr 2021 |