| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Luis Muriel | vs Nashville SC | 81' | Timothy Ford | MLS | 24 Aug 2025 |
| César Araujo | vs Atlanta United FC | 77' | Filip Dujic | MLS | 28 May 2025 |
| Rafael Santos | vs CF Montréal | 76' | Fotis Bazakos | MLS | 19 Apr 2025 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | vs Red Bull New York | 56' | Chris Penso | MLS | 12 Apr 2025 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | vs FC Cincinnati | 23' | Ismail Elfath | MLS | 4 May 2024 |
| Wilder Cartagena | vs Minnesota United FC | 90' | Wilmer Pino Mercado | MLS | 10 Mar 2024 |
| Wilder Cartagena | vs FC Cincinnati | 90' | Drew Fischer | MLS | 2 Sept 2023 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | vs Austin FC | 60' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 23 May 2022 |
| César Araujo | vs Austin FC | 69' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 23 May 2022 |
| Robin Jansson | vs CF Montréal | 81' | Marcos de Oliveira | MLS | 27 Feb 2022 |
| Antônio Carlos | vs Philadelphia Union | 88' | Alan Kelly | MLS | 19 Sept 2021 |
| Nani | vs CF Montréal | 35' | Rubiel Vazquez | MLS | 15 Sept 2021 |
| Andrés Perea | vs CF Montréal | 83' | Rubiel Vazquez | MLS | 15 Sept 2021 |
| Mauricio Pereyra | vs New England Revolution | 60' | – | MLS | 29 Nov 2020 |
| Ruan | vs New York City FC | 87' | – | MLS | 21 Nov 2020 |
| Pedro Gallese | vs New York City FC | 120' | – | MLS | 21 Nov 2020 |
| Nani | vs Columbus Crew | 52' | – | MLS | 5 Nov 2020 |
| Jhegson Méndez | vs FC Dallas | 69' | – | MLS | 28 Sept 2020 |
| Dom Dwyer | vs Columbus Crew | 90' | – | MLS | 13 Jul 2019 |
| Robin Jansson | vs Philadelphia Union | 45' | – | MLS | 3 Jul 2019 |
| Sacha Kljestan | vs Philadelphia Union | 67' | – | MLS | 3 Jul 2019 |
| Cristian Higuita | vs D.C. United | 55' | – | MLS | 13 Aug 2018 |
| Yoshimar Yotún | vs New England Revolution | 90' | – | MLS | 4 Aug 2018 |
| Shane O'Neill | vs New York City FC | 83' | – | MLS | 27 Jul 2018 |
| Mohamed El-Munir | vs Vancouver Whitecaps | 58' | – | MLS | 9 Jun 2018 |
| Victor Giro | vs D.C. United | 41' | – | MLS | 4 Mar 2018 |
| Jonathan Spector | vs Portland Timbers | 47' | – | MLS | 25 Sept 2017 |
| Victor Giro | vs Portland Timbers | 84' | – | MLS | 25 Sept 2017 |
| Servando Carrasco | vs D.C. United | 79' | – | MLS | 9 Sept 2017 |
| Seb Hines | vs D.C. United | 90' | – | MLS | 9 Sept 2017 |
| José Aja | vs New England Revolution | 80' | – | MLS | 2 Sept 2017 |
| Kaká | vs Red Bull New York | 90' | – | MLS | 12 Aug 2017 |
| Rafael Ramos | vs Chicago Fire FC | 26' | – | MLS | 4 Jun 2017 |
| Antonio Nocerino | vs Chicago Fire FC | 66' | – | MLS | 4 Jun 2017 |
| Antonio Nocerino | vs D.C. United | 66' | – | MLS | 24 Sept 2016 |
| David Mateos | vs Philadelphia Union | 90' | – | MLS | 25 May 2016 |
| Cristian Higuita | vs Red Bull New York | 85' | – | MLS | 6 May 2016 |
| Darwin Cerén | vs Real Salt Lake | 45' | – | MLS | 6 Mar 2016 |
| Cristian Higuita | vs Philadelphia Union | 86' | – | MLS | 25 Oct 2015 |
| Rafael Ramos | vs Toronto FC | 36' | – | MLS | 22 Aug 2015 |
| Adrian Winter | vs Toronto FC | 82' | – | MLS | 22 Aug 2015 |
| Tyler Turner | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 40' | – | MLS | 16 Aug 2015 |
| Cyle Larin | vs Red Bull New York | 32' | – | MLS | 18 Jul 2015 |
| Luke Boden | vs FC Dallas | 90' | – | MLS | 11 Jul 2015 |
| Kaká | vs Real Salt Lake | 45' | – | MLS | 5 Jul 2015 |
| Brek Shea | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 51' | – | MLS | 24 May 2015 |
| Rafael Ramos | vs Columbus Crew | 34' | – | MLS | 18 Apr 2015 |
| Aurélien Collin | vs New York City FC | 83' | – | MLS | 8 Mar 2015 |