| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lukas MacNaughton | D.C. United | vs Orlando City SC | 57' | MLS | 13 Sept 2025 |
| Wayne Frederick | Colorado Rapids | vs Portland Timbers | 67' | MLS | 29 May 2025 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | Orlando City SC | vs Red Bull New York | 56' | MLS | 12 Apr 2025 |
| Fafà Picault | Vancouver Whitecaps | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 88' | MLS | 3 Oct 2024 |
| Sergio Busquets | Inter Miami CF | vs FC Cincinnati | 62' | MLS | 6 Jul 2024 |
| Kévin Cabral | Colorado Rapids | vs LAFC | 62' | MLS | 30 Jun 2024 |
| Alvas Powell | FC Cincinnati | vs Red Bull New York | 88' | MLS | 4 Oct 2023 |
| Johnny Russell | Sporting Kansas City | vs Houston Dynamo FC | 39' | MLS | 24 Sept 2023 |
| Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty | Toronto FC | vs CF Montréal | 56' | MLS | 13 May 2023 |
| Dylan Borrero | New England Revolution | vs Columbus Crew | 65' | MLS | 15 Apr 2023 |
| Gustavo Vallecilla | Colorado Rapids | vs FC Dallas | 77' | MLS | 1 Oct 2022 |
| Walker Zimmerman | Nashville SC | vs LA Galaxy | 90' | MLS | 10 Sept 2022 |
| Jackson Ragen | Seattle Sounders FC | vs Portland Timbers | 46' | MLS | 9 Jul 2022 |
| Oriol Rosell | Sporting Kansas City | vs New England Revolution | 48' | MLS | 12 Jun 2022 |
| Dom Dwyer | Atlanta United FC | vs CF Montréal | 67' | MLS | 19 Mar 2022 |
| Lucas Esteves | Colorado Rapids | vs Seattle Sounders FC | 61' | MLS | 4 Oct 2021 |
| Alfredo Morales | New York City FC | vs New England Revolution | 53' | MLS | 11 Sept 2021 |
| Tristan Blackmon | LAFC | vs Sporting Kansas City | 58' | MLS | 26 Jun 2021 |
| Gabriel Farfán | Chivas USA | vs Colorado Rapids | 33' | MLS | 12 Aug 2013 |
| Tony Cascio | Colorado Rapids | vs Chivas USA | 49' | MLS | 12 Aug 2013 |
| Tristan Bowen | Chivas USA | vs Colorado Rapids | 63' | MLS | 12 Aug 2013 |
| Collen Warner | Real Salt Lake | vs Vancouver Whitecaps | 44' | MLS | 7 Oct 2011 |
| Emmanuel Ekpo | Columbus Crew | vs Houston Dynamo FC | 11' | MLS | 14 Sept 2011 |
| Teal Bunbury | Sporting Kansas City | vs FC Dallas | 77' | MLS | 28 Aug 2011 |
| Benny Feilhaber | New England Revolution | vs Philadelphia Union | 66' | MLS | 17 Jul 2011 |
| Shea Salinas | Vancouver Whitecaps | vs Columbus Crew | 77' | MLS | 7 Jul 2011 |