| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stian Gregersen | vs CF Montréal | 55' | Ted Unkel | MLS | 13 Jul 2024 |
| Brad Guzan | vs LAFC | 60' | Sergii Boiko | MLS | 25 May 2024 |
| Thiago Almada | vs FC Cincinnati | 51' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 21 Oct 2023 |
| Luiz Araújo | vs Chicago Fire FC | 71' | Rosendo Mendoza | MLS | 21 May 2023 |
| Andrew Gutman | vs Charlotte FC | 51' | Lukasz Szpala | MLS | 13 May 2023 |
| Franco Ibarra | vs New York City FC | 62' | Drew Fischer | MLS | 8 Apr 2023 |
| Thiago Almada | vs Columbus Crew | 90' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 28 May 2022 |
| Dom Dwyer | vs CF Montréal | 67' | Chris Penso | MLS | 19 Mar 2022 |
| Miles Robinson | vs Colorado Rapids | 86' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 5 Mar 2022 |
| Alan Franco | vs New York City FC | 90' | – | MLS | 21 Nov 2021 |
| Ezequiel Barco | vs Toronto FC | 84' | Timothy Ford | MLS | 16 Oct 2021 |
| Josef Martínez | vs CF Montréal | 82' | David Gantar | MLS | 4 Aug 2021 |
| Jake Mulraney | vs Nashville SC | 74' | Joseph Dickerson | MLS | 9 Jul 2021 |
| Franco Escobar | vs Columbus Crew | 90' | – | MLS | 8 Nov 2020 |
| Jake Mulraney | vs FC Cincinnati | 26' | – | MLS | 16 Jul 2020 |
| Jerome Williams | vs FC Cincinnati | 90' | – | MLS | 16 Jul 2020 |
| Jeff Larentowicz | vs Red Bull New York | 90' | – | MLS | 7 Jul 2019 |
| Leandro González Pírez | vs Chicago Fire FC | 11' | – | MLS | 4 Jul 2019 |
| Gregory Garza | vs Red Bull New York | 71' | – | MLS | 20 May 2018 |
| Brad Guzan | vs Sporting Kansas City | 34' | – | MLS | 9 May 2018 |
| Leandro González Pírez | vs Minnesota United FC | 38' | – | MLS | 1 Apr 2018 |
| Kyle Reynish | vs Minnesota United FC | 60' | – | MLS | 3 Oct 2017 |
| Brandon Vázquez | vs LA Galaxy | 82' | – | MLS | 20 Sept 2017 |
| Leandro González Pírez | vs CF Montréal | 45' | – | MLS | 15 Apr 2017 |
| Yamil Asad | vs Toronto FC | 75' | – | MLS | 8 Apr 2017 |
| Carlos Carmona | vs Red Bull New York | 88' | – | MLS | 6 Mar 2017 |