| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Erik Sviatchenko | Houston Dynamo FC | vs Nashville SC | 9' | MLS | 28 Sept 2025 |
| Tomás Avilés | Inter Miami CF | vs Charlotte FC | 79' | MLS | 13 Sept 2025 |
| Olwethu Makhanya | Philadelphia Union | vs FC Cincinnati | 60' | MLS | 30 Aug 2025 |
| Lalas Abubakar | FC Dallas | vs Philadelphia Union | 39' | MLS | 1 Jun 2025 |
| Ariath Piol | Real Salt Lake | vs FC Dallas | 23' | MLS | 23 Mar 2025 |
| Gilberto Flores | FC Cincinnati | vs Charlotte FC | 83' | MLS | 15 Mar 2025 |
| Hernan Lopez | San Jose Earthquakes | vs Sporting Kansas City | 52' | MLS | 2 Mar 2025 |
| Boris Enow | D.C. United | vs FC Dallas | 45' | MLS | 24 Aug 2024 |
| Sean Nealis | Red Bull New York | vs CF Montréal | 81' | MLS | 17 Jul 2024 |
| Brad Guzan | Atlanta United FC | vs LAFC | 60' | MLS | 25 May 2024 |
| Eduard Atuesta | LAFC | vs Atlanta United FC | 81' | MLS | 25 May 2024 |
| Andrés Reyes | Red Bull New York | vs Chicago Fire FC | 42' | MLS | 13 Apr 2024 |
| Daniel Lovitz | Nashville SC | vs Philadelphia Union | 81' | MLS | 13 Jul 2023 |
| Julián Carranza | Philadelphia Union | vs Nashville SC | 90' | MLS | 13 Jul 2023 |
| Shaq Moore | Nashville SC | vs Philadelphia Union | 90' | MLS | 13 Jul 2023 |
| Cucho Hernández | Columbus Crew | vs New York City FC | 68' | MLS | 8 Jul 2023 |
| Ian Murphy | FC Cincinnati | vs D.C. United | 79' | MLS | 24 Jun 2023 |
| Moïse Bombito | Colorado Rapids | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 51' | MLS | 4 Jun 2023 |