| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eddie Segura | vs LA Galaxy | 90' | Guido Gonzales Jr. | MLS | 20 Jul 2025 |
| Igor Jesus | vs San Diego FC | 53' | Tori Penso | MLS | 30 Mar 2025 |
| Lewis O'Brien | vs LA Galaxy | 79' | Ted Unkel | MLS | 15 Sept 2024 |
| Sergi Palencia | vs Columbus Crew | 83' | Lukasz Szpala | MLS | 14 Jul 2024 |
| Jesús Murillo | vs Columbus Crew | 90' | Lukasz Szpala | MLS | 14 Jul 2024 |
| Eduard Atuesta | vs Atlanta United FC | 81' | Sergii Boiko | MLS | 25 May 2024 |
| David Martínez | vs Colorado Rapids | 85' | Armando Villarreal | MLS | 30 Mar 2024 |
| Kwadwo Opoku | vs Houston Dynamo FC | 79' | Guido Gonzales Jr. | MLS | 15 Jun 2023 |
| Maxime Crépeau | vs Philadelphia Union | 116' | Ismail Elfath | MLS | 5 Nov 2022 |
| Ryan Hollingshead | vs FC Dallas | 13' | Jon Freemon | MLS | 11 Sept 2022 |
| Ilie Sánchez | vs San Jose Earthquakes | 79' | Michael Radchuk | MLS | 21 Aug 2022 |
| Tristan Blackmon | vs Sporting Kansas City | 58' | Chris Penso | MLS | 26 Jun 2021 |
| Mark-Anthony Kaye | vs LA Galaxy | 53' | – | MLS | 7 Sept 2020 |
| Walker Zimmerman | vs Real Salt Lake | 48' | – | MLS | 18 Aug 2019 |
| Lee Nguyen | vs Portland Timbers | 84' | – | MLS | 15 Jul 2018 |
| Jordan Harvey | vs FC Dallas | 89' | – | MLS | 3 Jun 2018 |
| Dejan Janković | vs D.C. United | 45' | – | MLS | 27 May 2018 |
| Joao Moutinho | vs Atlanta United FC | 90' | – | MLS | 7 Apr 2018 |