| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matti Peltola | D.C. United | vs CF Montréal | 45' | MLS | 29 May 2024 |
| Rodrigo Schlegel | Orlando City SC | vs FC Cincinnati | 23' | MLS | 4 May 2024 |
| Bret Halsey | FC Cincinnati | vs Orlando City SC | 78' | MLS | 4 May 2024 |
| Diego Chará | Portland Timbers | vs LAFC | 76' | MLS | 28 Apr 2024 |
| Yerson Mosquera | FC Cincinnati | vs Philadelphia Union | 83' | MLS | 16 Sept 2023 |
| Jack Elliott | Philadelphia Union | vs FC Cincinnati | 90' | MLS | 16 Sept 2023 |
| Gastón Giménez | Chicago Fire FC | vs LA Galaxy | 27' | MLS | 27 Aug 2023 |
| Rodney Redes | Austin FC | vs FC Dallas | 54' | MLS | 14 May 2023 |
| Vincent Aboubakar | Cameroon | vs Brazil | 90' | 2022 FIFA World Cup | 2 Dec 2022 |
| Maxime Crépeau | LAFC | vs Philadelphia Union | 116' | MLS | 5 Nov 2022 |
| Franco Fragapane | Minnesota United FC | vs FC Dallas | 69' | MLS | 3 Sept 2022 |
| Damion Lowe | Inter Miami CF | vs New England Revolution | 60' | MLS | 30 Apr 2022 |
| Jairo Quinteros | Inter Miami CF | vs New England Revolution | 76' | MLS | 30 Apr 2022 |
| Claudio Bravo | Portland Timbers | vs LAFC | 62' | MLS | 7 Mar 2022 |
| Keaton Parks | New York City FC | vs Red Bull New York | 73' | MLS | 23 Sept 2021 |
| Maxime Chanot | New York City FC | vs Red Bull New York | 90' | MLS | 23 Sept 2021 |
| José Andrés Martínez | Philadelphia Union | vs New York City FC | 16' | MLS | 1 May 2021 |
| Victor Palsson | Red Bull New York | vs CF Montréal | 58' | MLS | 19 May 2012 |