| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Surman | AFC Bournemouth | vs Manchester United | 45' | Premier League | 4 Mar 2017 |
| Wes Brown | Sunderland | vs Stoke City | 36' | Premier League | 23 Nov 2013 |
| Jay Spearing | Liverpool | vs Fulham | 72' | Premier League | 5 Dec 2011 |
| Craig Gardner | Birmingham City | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 29' | Premier League | 1 May 2011 |
| John Mensah | Sunderland | vs Liverpool | 82' | Premier League | 20 Mar 2011 |
| Gary Caldwell | Wigan Athletic | vs Arsenal | 70' | Premier League | 22 Jan 2011 |
| Jussi Jaaskelainen | Bolton Wanderers | vs Birmingham City | 36' | Premier League | 29 Aug 2010 |