| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lewis Cook | vs Sunderland | 90' | Tim Robinson | Premier League | 29 Nov 2025 |
| Lewis Cook | vs Manchester City | 73' | Thomas Bramall | Premier League | 20 May 2025 |
| Evanilson | vs Manchester United | 70' | Peter Bankes | Premier League | 27 Apr 2025 |
| Illia Zabarnyi | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 31' | Michael Salisbury | Premier League | 22 Feb 2025 |
| Milos Kerkez | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 79' | Stuart Attwell | Premier League | 24 Apr 2024 |
| Philip Billing | vs Nottingham Forest | 84' | Rebecca Welch | Premier League | 4 Feb 2024 |
| Lewis Cook | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 54' | Paul Tierney | Premier League | 21 Oct 2023 |
| Jefferson Lerma | vs Aston Villa | 51' | – | Premier League | 1 Feb 2020 |
| Steve Cook | vs Norwich City | 31' | – | Premier League | 18 Jan 2020 |
| Simon Francis | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 37' | – | Premier League | 23 Nov 2019 |
| Adam Smith | vs Everton | 61' | – | Premier League | 25 Aug 2018 |
| Simon Francis | vs Huddersfield Town | 45' | – | Premier League | 18 Nov 2017 |
| Andrew Surman | vs Manchester United | 45' | K Friend | Premier League | 4 Mar 2017 |
| Simon Francis | vs Arsenal | 82' | Michael Oliver | Premier League | 3 Jan 2017 |
| Harry Arter | vs West Ham United | 77' | Craig Pawson | Premier League | 21 Aug 2016 |
| Simon Francis | vs Leicester City | 57' | – | Premier League | 2 Jan 2016 |