| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cristian Romero | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Manchester United | 29' | Premier League | 7 Feb 2026 |
| Lesley Ugochukwu | Burnley | vs Liverpool | 84' | Premier League | 14 Sept 2025 |
| Nordi Mukiele | Bayer Leverkusen | vs Bayern Munich | 62' | UEFA Champions League | 5 Mar 2025 |
| Curtis Jones | Liverpool | vs Everton | 90' | Premier League | 12 Feb 2025 |
| Abdoulaye Doucouré | Everton | vs Liverpool | 90' | Premier League | 12 Feb 2025 |
| Myles Lewis-Skelly | Arsenal | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 43' | Premier League | 25 Jan 2025 |
| João Gomes | Wolverhampton Wanderers | vs Arsenal | 70' | Premier League | 25 Jan 2025 |
| Arnau Martínez | Girona | vs PSV Eindhoven | 55' | UEFA Champions League | 5 Nov 2024 |
| Leandro Trossard | Arsenal | vs Manchester City | 45' | Premier League | 22 Sept 2024 |
| Dara O'Shea | Burnley | vs Everton | 67' | Premier League | 6 Apr 2024 |
| Diogo Dalot | Manchester United | vs Liverpool | 90' | Premier League | 17 Dec 2023 |
| Fabio Vieira | Arsenal | vs Burnley | 83' | Premier League | 11 Nov 2023 |
| Cristian Romero | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Chelsea | 33' | Premier League | 6 Nov 2023 |
| Destiny Udogie | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Chelsea | 55' | Premier League | 6 Nov 2023 |
| Benjamin Pavard | Bayern Munich | vs Paris Saint-Germain | 90' | UEFA Champions League | 14 Feb 2023 |
| Douglas Luiz | Aston Villa | vs Fulham | 62' | Premier League | 20 Oct 2022 |
| Jarrad Branthwaite | Everton | vs Brentford | 18' | Premier League | 15 May 2022 |
| Salomón Rondón | Everton | vs Brentford | 88' | Premier League | 15 May 2022 |
| Craig Dawson | West Ham United | vs Chelsea | 86' | Premier League | 24 Apr 2022 |
| Michael Keane | Everton | vs West Ham United | 65' | Premier League | 3 Apr 2022 |
| Laurent Koscielny | Arsenal | vs Everton | 14' | Premier League | 21 May 2017 |
| Jeff Hendrick | Burnley | vs Watford | 6' | Premier League | 4 Feb 2017 |
| Simon Francis | AFC Bournemouth | vs Arsenal | 82' | Premier League | 3 Jan 2017 |
| Younes Kaboul | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Chelsea | 59' | Premier League | 8 Mar 2014 |
| Antonio Valencia | Manchester United | vs Hull City | 90' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2013 |
| Kevin Nolan | West Ham United | vs Liverpool | 82' | Premier League | 7 Dec 2013 |
| Simon Cziommer | Vitesse | vs Anzhi Makhachkala | 59' | UEFA Europa League | 9 Aug 2012 |
| Karl Henry | Wolverhampton Wanderers | vs Aston Villa | 74' | Premier League | 21 Jan 2012 |
| Gary Caldwell | Wigan Athletic | vs Stoke City | 75' | Premier League | 31 Dec 2011 |
| David Wheater | Bolton Wanderers | vs Everton | 19' | Premier League | 26 Nov 2011 |
| Armand Traore | Queens Park Rangers | vs Aston Villa | 90' | Premier League | 25 Sept 2011 |
| Pablo Ibáñez | West Bromwich Albion | vs Blackpool | 11' | Premier League | 1 Nov 2010 |
| Gonzalo Jara | West Bromwich Albion | vs Blackpool | 29' | Premier League | 1 Nov 2010 |