| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semi Ajayi | vs Burnley | 30' | – | Premier League | 20 Feb 2021 |
| Jake Livermore | vs Aston Villa | 37' | – | Premier League | 20 Dec 2020 |
| Matheus Pereira | vs Crystal Palace | 34' | – | Premier League | 6 Dec 2020 |
| Kieran Gibbs | vs Everton | 45' | – | Premier League | 19 Sept 2020 |
| Hal Robson-Kanu | vs Burnley | 83' | – | Premier League | 19 Aug 2017 |
| James McClean | vs AFC Bournemouth | 34' | – | Premier League | 19 Dec 2015 |
| Salomón Rondón | vs AFC Bournemouth | 90' | – | Premier League | 19 Dec 2015 |
| Gareth McAuley | vs Manchester United | 90' | – | Premier League | 7 Nov 2015 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | vs Queens Park Rangers | 84' | – | Premier League | 4 Apr 2015 |
| Gareth McAuley | vs Manchester City | 2' | – | Premier League | 21 Mar 2015 |
| Claudio Yacob | vs Chelsea | 29' | – | Premier League | 22 Nov 2014 |
| Marc-Antoine Fortuné | vs Southampton | 70' | – | Premier League | 27 Apr 2013 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | vs West Ham United | 90' | – | Premier League | 30 Mar 2013 |
| Goran Popov | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 47' | – | Premier League | 3 Feb 2013 |
| Peter Odemwingie | vs Fulham | 38' | – | Premier League | 15 Sept 2012 |
| Jonas Olsson | vs Manchester United | 66' | Lee Probert | Premier League | 11 Mar 2012 |
| Paul Scharner | vs Aston Villa | 62' | P Dowd | Premier League | 30 Apr 2011 |
| Gabriel Tamas | vs Blackburn Rovers | 87' | P Dowd | Premier League | 28 Dec 2010 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | vs Everton | 88' | L Mason | Premier League | 27 Nov 2010 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | vs Manchester City | 82' | Lee Probert | Premier League | 7 Nov 2010 |
| Pablo Ibáñez | vs Blackpool | 11' | Michael Oliver | Premier League | 1 Nov 2010 |
| Gonzalo Jara | vs Blackpool | 29' | Michael Oliver | Premier League | 1 Nov 2010 |
| James Morrison | vs Liverpool | 86' | Lee Probert | Premier League | 29 Aug 2010 |