| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sebastian Prödl | Watford | vs Chelsea | 90' | Premier League | 15 May 2017 |
| Papy Djilobodji | Sunderland | vs Hull City | 89' | Premier League | 19 Nov 2016 |
| Vincent Kompany | Manchester City | vs Hull City | 10' | Premier League | 15 Mar 2014 |
| Mathieu Flamini | Arsenal | vs Southampton | 80' | Premier League | 28 Jan 2014 |
| James Tomkins | West Ham United | vs Cardiff City | 72' | Premier League | 11 Jan 2014 |
| Mathieu Debuchy | Newcastle United | vs West Bromwich Albion | 62' | Premier League | 1 Jan 2014 |
| Mark Noble | West Ham United | vs Everton | 81' | Premier League | 21 Sept 2013 |
| Shaun Derry | Queens Park Rangers | vs Manchester United | 14' | Premier League | 8 Apr 2012 |
| Mikel Arteta | Everton | vs West Bromwich Albion | 58' | Premier League | 27 Nov 2010 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | West Bromwich Albion | vs Everton | 88' | Premier League | 27 Nov 2010 |
| Karl Henry | Wolverhampton Wanderers | vs Wigan Athletic | 11' | Premier League | 2 Oct 2010 |