| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hassane Kamara | vs Crystal Palace | 68' | Graham Scott | Premier League | 7 May 2022 |
| Emmanuel Dennis | vs Norwich City | 78' | – | Premier League | 21 Jan 2022 |
| Juraj Kucka | vs Arsenal | 89' | Kevin Friend | Premier League | 7 Nov 2021 |
| Christian Kabasele | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 71' | – | Premier League | 1 Jan 2020 |
| Adrian Mariappa | vs Aston Villa | 57' | – | Premier League | 28 Dec 2019 |
| Christian Kabasele | vs Norwich City | 65' | – | Premier League | 8 Nov 2019 |
| José Holebas | vs West Ham United | 48' | – | Premier League | 12 May 2019 |
| Troy Deeney | vs Arsenal | 11' | – | Premier League | 15 Apr 2019 |
| Étienne Capoue | vs Leicester City | 90' | – | Premier League | 1 Dec 2018 |
| Christian Kabasele | vs AFC Bournemouth | 32' | – | Premier League | 6 Oct 2018 |
| Troy Deeney | vs Huddersfield Town | 33' | – | Premier League | 16 Dec 2017 |
| Tom Cleverley | vs Crystal Palace | 87' | – | Premier League | 12 Dec 2017 |
| Marvin Zeegelaar | vs Burnley | 39' | – | Premier League | 9 Dec 2017 |
| Miguel Britos | vs Brighton & Hove Albion | 24' | – | Premier League | 26 Aug 2017 |
| Sebastian Prödl | vs Chelsea | 90' | L Mason | Premier League | 15 May 2017 |
| Miguel Britos | vs West Bromwich Albion | 65' | Paul Tierney | Premier League | 4 Apr 2017 |
| Roberto Pereyra | vs West Bromwich Albion | 84' | G Scott | Premier League | 3 Dec 2016 |
| Miguel Britos | vs Stoke City | 90' | M Atkinson | Premier League | 27 Nov 2016 |
| Ben Watson | vs Southampton | 76' | Roger East | Premier League | 13 Aug 2016 |
| Nordin Amrabat | vs West Ham United | 90' | – | Premier League | 20 Apr 2016 |
| Nathan Aké | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 63' | – | Premier League | 28 Dec 2015 |
| Valon Behrami | vs Swansea City | 64' | – | Premier League | 12 Sept 2015 |