| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marouane Fellaini | Manchester United | vs Manchester City | 84' | Premier League | 27 Apr 2017 |
| Ashley Barnes | Burnley | vs Hull City | 90' | Premier League | 25 Feb 2017 |
| Miguel Britos | Watford | vs Stoke City | 90' | Premier League | 27 Nov 2016 |
| Aaron Cresswell | West Ham United | vs Crystal Palace | 75' | Premier League | 15 Oct 2016 |
| Glenn Whelan | Stoke City | vs Newcastle United | 40' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2013 |
| Marc Wilson | Stoke City | vs Newcastle United | 43' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2013 |
| Mario Balotelli | Manchester City | vs Arsenal | 90' | Premier League | 8 Apr 2012 |
| Pepe Reina | Liverpool | vs Newcastle United | 83' | Premier League | 1 Apr 2012 |
| Robert Huth | Stoke City | vs Sunderland | 44' | Premier League | 4 Feb 2012 |
| Dan Gosling | Newcastle United | vs Norwich City | 66' | Premier League | 10 Dec 2011 |
| Mario Balotelli | Manchester City | vs Liverpool | 83' | Premier League | 27 Nov 2011 |
| Jack Rodwell | Everton | vs Liverpool | 23' | Premier League | 1 Oct 2011 |
| Martin Olsson | Blackburn Rovers | vs Newcastle United | 69' | Premier League | 24 Sept 2011 |
| Emmanuel Frimpong | Arsenal | vs Liverpool | 70' | Premier League | 20 Aug 2011 |
| Clint Hill | Queens Park Rangers | vs Bolton Wanderers | 90' | Premier League | 13 Aug 2011 |
| Zoltan Gera | Fulham | vs Arsenal | 74' | Premier League | 22 May 2011 |
| Nemanja Vidic | Manchester United | vs Chelsea | 90' | Premier League | 1 Mar 2011 |
| Ryan Nelsen | Blackburn Rovers | vs Aston Villa | 90' | Premier League | 26 Feb 2011 |
| Jermain Defoe | Tottenham Hotspur | vs Aston Villa | 27' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2010 |
| Antolin Alcaraz | Wigan Athletic | vs Manchester United | 59' | Premier League | 20 Nov 2010 |
| Hugo Rodallega | Wigan Athletic | vs Manchester United | 61' | Premier League | 20 Nov 2010 |
| Michael Essien | Chelsea | vs Fulham | 90' | Premier League | 10 Nov 2010 |
| Ryan Shawcross | Stoke City | vs Sunderland | 82' | Premier League | 6 Nov 2010 |
| Jack Wilshere | Arsenal | vs Birmingham City | 90' | Premier League | 16 Oct 2010 |
| Joe Cole | Liverpool | vs Arsenal | 45' | Premier League | 15 Aug 2010 |
| Laurent Koscielny | Arsenal | vs Liverpool | 90' | Premier League | 15 Aug 2010 |