| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frank Anguissa | Fulham | vs Manchester United | 68' | Premier League | 8 Dec 2018 |
| Tim Howard | Everton | vs Sunderland | 23' | Premier League | 26 Dec 2013 |
| John O'Shea | Sunderland | vs Crystal Palace | 78' | Premier League | 31 Aug 2013 |
| Anthony Modeste | Blackburn Rovers | vs West Bromwich Albion | 89' | Premier League | 7 Apr 2012 |
| Jonas Olsson | West Bromwich Albion | vs Manchester United | 66' | Premier League | 11 Mar 2012 |
| Johan Djourou | Arsenal | vs Fulham | 78' | Premier League | 2 Jan 2012 |
| Clement Chantome | Paris Saint-Germain | vs Slovan Bratislava | 64' | UEFA Europa League | 20 Oct 2011 |
| Siaka Tiéné | Paris Saint-Germain | vs Slovan Bratislava | 80' | UEFA Europa League | 20 Oct 2011 |
| Charles N'Zogbia | Wigan Athletic | vs Arsenal | 78' | Premier League | 29 Dec 2010 |
| Mario Balotelli | Manchester City | vs West Bromwich Albion | 62' | Premier League | 7 Nov 2010 |
| Youssouf Mulumbu | West Bromwich Albion | vs Manchester City | 82' | Premier League | 7 Nov 2010 |
| Christopher Samba | Blackburn Rovers | vs Sunderland | 45' | Premier League | 18 Oct 2010 |
| James Morrison | West Bromwich Albion | vs Liverpool | 86' | Premier League | 29 Aug 2010 |