| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Harry Maguire | Manchester United | vs AFC Bournemouth | 78' | Premier League | 20 Mar 2026 |
| Lucas Pires | Burnley | vs Newcastle United | 43' | Premier League | 6 Dec 2025 |
| Dan Burn | Newcastle United | vs Brentford | 73' | Premier League | 9 Nov 2025 |
| Jacob Ramsey | Aston Villa | vs AFC Bournemouth | 80' | Premier League | 10 May 2025 |
| Carlos Baleba | Brighton & Hove Albion | vs AFC Bournemouth | 59' | Premier League | 23 Nov 2024 |
| Jack Stephens | Southampton | vs Manchester United | 79' | Premier League | 14 Sept 2024 |
| Milos Kerkez | AFC Bournemouth | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 79' | Premier League | 24 Apr 2024 |
| Mason Holgate | Sheffield United | vs Brighton & Hove Albion | 13' | Premier League | 18 Feb 2024 |
| Sander Berge | Burnley | vs Aston Villa | 56' | Premier League | 30 Dec 2023 |
| Joe Worrall | Nottingham Forest | vs Manchester United | 67' | Premier League | 26 Aug 2023 |
| Luis Sinisterra | Leeds United | vs Aston Villa | 48' | Premier League | 2 Oct 2022 |
| Kalidou Koulibaly | Chelsea | vs Leeds United | 84' | Premier League | 21 Aug 2022 |
| David Luiz | Arsenal | vs Chelsea | 26' | Premier League | 21 Jan 2020 |
| Nenad Milijas | Wolverhampton Wanderers | vs Arsenal | 75' | Premier League | 27 Dec 2011 |
| Gary Cahill | Bolton Wanderers | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 18' | Premier League | 3 Dec 2011 |
| Vincent Kompany | Manchester City | vs Wolverhampton Wanderers | 74' | Premier League | 29 Oct 2011 |
| Ryan Shawcross | Stoke City | vs Fulham | 54' | Premier League | 22 Jan 2011 |
| Gary Cahill | Bolton Wanderers | vs Arsenal | 64' | Premier League | 11 Sept 2010 |