| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anel Ahmedhodzic | vs Nottingham Forest | 90' | Chris Kavanagh | Premier League | 4 May 2024 |
| Mason Holgate | vs Brighton & Hove Albion | 13' | Stuart Attwell | Premier League | 18 Feb 2024 |
| Rhian Brewster | vs West Ham United | 90' | Michael Salisbury | Premier League | 21 Jan 2024 |
| Oliver McBurnie | vs Burnley | 45' | Chris Kavanagh | Premier League | 2 Dec 2023 |
| Oliver McBurnie | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 90' | Peter Bankes | Premier League | 16 Sept 2023 |
| Phil Jagielka | vs Aston Villa | 57' | – | Premier League | 3 Mar 2021 |
| John Lundstram | vs Brighton & Hove Albion | 40' | – | Premier League | 20 Dec 2020 |
| John Egan | vs Aston Villa | 12' | – | Premier League | 21 Sept 2020 |
| Billy Sharp | vs Southampton | 85' | – | Premier League | 14 Sept 2019 |