| Player | Team | Opponent | Min | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Virgil van Dijk | Southampton | vs West Bromwich Albion | 89' | Premier League | 31 Dec 2016 |
| Wes Brown | Sunderland | vs Hull City | 4' | Premier League | 8 Feb 2014 |
| Yannick Sagbo | Hull City | vs Norwich City | 27' | Premier League | 24 Aug 2013 |
| Djibril Cissé | Queens Park Rangers | vs Sunderland | 55' | Premier League | 24 Mar 2012 |
| Gareth Barry | Manchester City | vs Liverpool | 73' | Premier League | 3 Jan 2012 |
| Jonás Gutiérrez | Newcastle United | vs Manchester United | 79' | Premier League | 26 Nov 2011 |
| Charlie Adam | Liverpool | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 28' | Premier League | 18 Sept 2011 |
| Martin Skrtel | Liverpool | vs Tottenham Hotspur | 63' | Premier League | 18 Sept 2011 |
| John Ruddy | Norwich City | vs Chelsea | 80' | Premier League | 27 Aug 2011 |
| Pablo Zabaleta | Manchester City | vs Arsenal | 89' | Premier League | 5 Jan 2011 |
| Bacary Sagna | Arsenal | vs Manchester City | 89' | Premier League | 5 Jan 2011 |