| Player | Opponent | Min | Referee | Competition | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pablo Mastroeni | vs Italy | 45' | Jorge Larrionda | 2006 FIFA World Cup | 17 Jun 2006 |
| Eddie Pope | vs Italy | 47' | Jorge Larrionda | 2006 FIFA World Cup | 17 Jun 2006 |
| Fernando Clavijo | vs Brazil | 85' | Joël Quiniou | 1994 FIFA World Cup | 4 Jul 1994 |
| Eric Wynalda | vs Czechoslovakia | 52' | Kurt Röthlisberger | 1990 FIFA World Cup | 10 Jun 1990 |